Roth, Whether You Like It or Not

Kristan Anderson, CEBS®, CFP® |

My most recent take-home pay was noticeably lower than previous ones. I did some investigating into why and found that I had recently reached the maximum regular annual contribution limit ($24,500) to my 401(k). Remember back in 2024 when we wrote about a proposed provision that was going to require many eligible participants’ catch-up contributions (additional contributions beyond the annual contribution limit for older employees) to be directed to a Roth option in their retirement plan? Well, since I’m over 50, my catch-up contributions have shifted to the after-tax Roth option, which means I am no longer getting a tax deduction. It also means my taxable income is higher, resulting in higher taxes and lower take home pay.

To be clear, the Roth catch-up provisions are only relevant to a specific population, namely participants aged 50 or older and who had FICA wages that exceeded $150,000 in the prior year. If you are younger than 50, you do not have the option of contributing beyond the annual limits. If you are older than age 50 but earning less than $150,000, then you have the option of directing where to direct any catch-up, either to pre-tax or to Roth.

Having been confronted with the very real tax implications of shifting from one form of contribution to another without planning for the cash flow shift, I thought it might be good to revisit the differences and advantages of pre-tax regular contributions vs. after-tax Roth contributions.

So, what should you be looking at to determine whether to contribute pre-tax or through the Roth option (or a combination of both) to your retirement plan? If you are younger and have a relatively low income, starting with Roth contributions may be a good way to build savings that you can access tax free in retirement. With the Roth option, any amount you contribute reduces your pay dollar-for-dollar. In a sense, it is an easy calculation that you can adjust as needed to either increase take home pay (lower contribution) or save more (higher contribution).

Here’s some additional information that might favor Roth contributions. You are generally able to withdraw any contribution you made to the Roth 401(k) plan, with no age restrictions, tax-free, and without penalty. However, any earnings associated with those contributions need to meet a 5-year rule and you will be taxed and penalized on those earnings if withdrawn earlier than age 59½. Note that Roth IRAs have a different set of rules that allows you to cherry-pick contributions first for maximum tax efficiency. In the Roth 401(k) any early withdrawals must be prorated between contributions and earnings.

Here’s an example of how that might work. You contribute $10,000 to the Roth portion of your plan and that grows over the next two years to $15,000. If you determine that you need to take $5,000 out of the plan after 5 years and are over 59½, you can do so without tax or penalty, because it is within the amount that you contributed. However, if you take an early distribution, that same $5,000 would consist of $2,500 contribution (not taxed) and $2,500 earnings (taxed) based on a 50% earnings ratio ($5,000 earnings / $10,000 contribution). You will also pay $250 in penalties on the earnings portion of the distribution ($2,500 * 10%).

The goal for retirement savings is to leave the plan intact until you need those assets to fund cash flow once you stop earning a paycheck. How then do you choose between the after-tax Roth option and the more traditional pre-tax contribution? When you contribute to a pre-tax plan, your take-home pay will be higher because of the tax savings associated with the contribution (pre-tax means that you are not paying regular income taxes on this amount). In that respect, most people agree that the traditional contribution method has a big benefit. 

However, once you have been contributing for a while, and potentially receiving contributions from your employer, those balances will grow and eventually you must pay taxes on the amounts you withdraw. As mentioned above, the Roth option does not give you an immediate tax benefit but rather becomes a tax-free asset that you can draw on in retirement. Here’s a chart showing what that looks like for both options, assuming a $7,500 annual contribution over a 20-year period with 7 percent growth. 

 

Pre-tax

After-tax Roth

Total contributed

$150,000

$150,000

Balance after 20 years

$307,466

$307,466

After-tax value of balance (24% tax bracket)

$233,674

$307,466

In general, if you feel like you will be in at least the 22 percent tax bracket in retirement, making Roth contributions will yield a larger after-tax asset.

The best way to determine for yourself what type of contribution to make is to model your paycheck with both pre-tax and Roth contributions, or a combination of both, to see what your take-home pay looks like. We like the online calculator paycheckcity, but your retirement plan provider likely has an option for you to do some estimating before committing.

Finally, be mindful of the fact that many plans now have an auto-enrollment feature which defaults to pre-tax contributions. This is yet another reason to not let your retirement plan participation go entirely on autopilot. And if you are older and have higher annual earnings, be mindful of that shift into full Roth contribution mode for catch-up contributions, regardless of your regular contribution preferences, as it will impact your take home pay.

Meet Kristan Anderson, CEBS®, CFP®

Read the November 2026 Financial Planning Focus: